Personal Pension Planning: Securing Your Retirement

Start early to maintain your standard of living in retirement


Many people in the UK rely on the State Pension for their retirement. However, it is unlikely to be enough on its own to maintain your standard of living in later life because of the pension gap. That is why personal pension planning is becoming increasingly important alongside the State Pension and workplace pensions. For those with many years until retirement, it offers a wide range of ways to close the gap. But what options are available? Do they offer good returns at low risk, and are they a sound choice?

In this guide, we answer these questions and more, looking closely at the main options for personal pension planning and their pros and cons.

The essentials in brief:
Personal Pension Planning at a Glance

  • Definition: Personal pension planning is an individual financial plan for retirement that relies on a high degree of personal responsibility. Alongside the State Pension and workplace pensions, it is essential for maintaining your standard of living in retirement.

  • Options: There are many ways to save for retirement privately. These include workplace pensions, SIPPs, insurance-based pension plans, endowment policies and Stocks and Shares ISAs, as well as regular ETF investing and regular fund investing.

  • Costs, returns and taxes: Assess every option on costs, returns and tax. Each has a decisive impact on how much retirement income you end up with.

Advert
Get started with ETF investing

Find and compare thousands of ETFs. Use powerful filters, detailed analytics, and independent data to discover the right ETF for your portfolio.

Definition: What is personal pension planning?

Personal pension planning is the third pillar of the three-pillar model of retirement planning, alongside the State Pension and workplace pensions. Its goal is to build up enough assets to maintain your accustomed standard of living once you retire. It relies largely on individual responsibility.

The following chart provides an overview of the three-pillar model of retirement planning, in which personal pension planning plays an essential role in closing the pension gap:

Personal pension planning as an important part of the three-pillar model of retirement provision
Source: extraETF Research, as at December 2023.

Why is personal pension planning a good idea?

Personal pension planning is both sensible and essential, as the State Pension alone will not be enough to close the pension gap and maintain your standard of living in retirement. The main reasons are demographic change and rising life expectancy. Personal pension planning is also a wise choice because you can tailor it flexibly to your own circumstances.

If you still have many years until retirement and can regularly set aside an amount for your pension, compound growth can build a substantial pot for later life. This assumes you choose low-risk options that are expected to deliver strong returns and growth over the long term, such as suitable ETFs.

Options for Personal Pension Planning

Examples of personal pension planning options include:

  • Workplace pension (auto-enrolment)
  • SIPP (Self-Invested Personal Pension)
  • Insurance-based pension plan
  • Endowment policy
  • Regular fund investing and ETFs
  • Stocks and Shares ISA

Note: None of these options is right for everyone. Before making any decision about retirement savings, thoroughly evaluate the advantages and disadvantages of each option and decide whether it suits your situation.

Before we weigh up the pros and cons of each approach, let’s look at each option in more detail.

Be mindful of the costs, potential returns, and risks

Martin Vogt, extraETFMartin Vogt, Education & Content Manager
High costs can significantly reduce the overall return on your retirement savings. A difference of 1–2 per cent in fees may not seem like much at first, but over the long run it can cost you many thousands of pounds. Before investing, carefully review the costs you can expect, what returns are realistic and what risks are involved.
Martin Vogt, Education & Content Manager

How much should you save each month for your personal pension?

How much you should save and invest each month depends on many factors, including your financial situation, the type of investment, your investment horizon, the rate of return, any existing pension provision, the standard of living you want in retirement, inflation and taxes. Our article on the pension gap explains everything you need to know, while the extraETF pension gap calculator can help you work out the size of your own gap.

A solid grasp of finance is essential for personal pension planning. Our ETF Guide, among other resources, covers everything you need to know about investing with ETFs.

Join the extraETF community

Werde Teil der extraETF Community

Explore the world of ETFs and make informed investment decisions.

  • Find ETFs that match your criteria with our ETF Search.
  • Compare costs, performance, and risk side by side.
  • Save your favourites to a watchlist and receive price alerts.
  • Explore detailed ETF profiles with key metrics and holdings.

Advantages and Disadvantages of Various Personal Pension Planning Plans

Each personal pension option has its own advantages and disadvantages, which you should weigh carefully against your circumstances and finances to find the plan that best suits your needs. Please note that the points below are not exhaustive. Many investment options also come in specialised forms and product variations, each with its own characteristics.

Benefits of Personal Pension Planning

Types of Personal Pension PlanAdvantages
Workplace Pension (Auto-Enrolment)
  • Employer contributions and tax relief
  • Contributions taken automatically from your pay
  • Often a good option for low- and middle-income earners
  • Option of a guaranteed lifetime income (annuity)
SIPP
  • Suitable for the self-employed and freelancers
  • Tax relief on contributions
  • Wide choice of investments, including ETFs and funds
  • Option of a guaranteed lifetime income (annuity)
Insurance-Based Pension Plan
  • Various options available
  • Easy to plan for
  • Part of the pension pot can usually be taken tax-free
  • Lifetime annuity payments or a lump sum are possible
Endowment Policy
  • Full lump-sum payout possible
  • Payout at the end of the term or to beneficiaries on death
Regular Fund Investing & ETFs
  • High returns possible
  • Broad risk diversification
  • For ETFs: low costs, high transparency, flexible tradability, low long-term risk for global equity ETFs, status as a segregated fund
Stocks and Shares ISA
  • High returns possible
  • No UK tax on income, gains or withdrawals
  • Flexible access at any age
  • Low-cost options available

Disadvantages of Personal Pension Planning

Types of Personal Pension PlanDisadvantages
Workplace Pension (Auto-Enrolment)
  • Fund choice can be limited in some schemes
  • No access before the minimum pension age (currently 55, rising to 57 in 2028)
  • Income beyond the tax-free portion is taxable
  • Charges vary between schemes and can be high
SIPP
  • No access before the minimum pension age (currently 55, rising to 57 in 2028)
  • Platform and investment charges apply
  • Income beyond the tax-free portion is taxable
  • Value can fall, and you make the investment decisions yourself
Insurance-Based Pension Plan
  • Often high costs
  • Low potential returns
  • Losses are possible if the policy is terminated early
  • Retirement income can be very low
  • So-called “indexed policies” are unpredictable and lack transparency
Endowment Policy
  • Low returns
  • A medical exam may be required, depending on the policy
  • Long-term commitment to the insurer
  • Not flexible when life circumstances change
Regular Fund Investing & ETFs
  • Risks of ETFs:
  • Fluctuations in value
  • Choosing ETFs that are not sufficiently diversified, such as thematic ETFs
  • Counterparty risk with swap ETFs
  • Risk from investor behaviour, especially when financial knowledge is limited
  • Risks of active funds:
  • High costs due to active fund management
  • Generally lower long-term returns than ETFs
  • Opaque investment decisions by fund managers, which may prove flawed

For more detailed information, see our article on the difference between ETFs and actively managed funds.

Stocks and Shares ISA
  • Value can fall as well as rise
  • Annual limit of £20,000 across all ISAs
  • No tax relief on contributions

Conclusion:
Why Personal Pension Planning Are Important

Today, personal pension planning has become indispensable alongside workplace pensions, as the State Pension alone is not enough to maintain your standard of living in later life. There are many options – including workplace pensions, SIPPs, insurance-based pension plans, Stocks and Shares ISAs, ETFs and endowment policies – and each has its own advantages and disadvantages.

When choosing a personal pension plan, always assess carefully how well it suits you and your situation. Don’t let tax benefits blind you; instead, pay close attention to costs, risks and overall return. After all, once you start drawing your pension, what really matters is having enough income to close your pension gap.

Among all the options, long-term investment in sufficiently diversified global equity ETFs is an excellent choice for your retirement savings. They offer low costs and high potential returns, with lower risk thanks to broad diversification. A regular ETF investment plan makes particular sense if you still have many years or decades until retirement and can invest each month. With the extraETF regular investing calculator, you can run sample scenarios in advance, and in our comparison of regular ETF investment plans you’ll find the one that best suits you and your situation.

We're here to answer any other questions you may have about private retirement planning