ETF Investment Strategies

How to find the right investment strategy for your goals


Anyone who wants to invest their money profitably in the stock market needs a suitable investment strategy. It provides a long-term framework for buying and selling ETFs, stocks, bonds, or other securities. Investment strategies using ETFs are based not only on objective criteria – such as fundamental and technical analysis of securities, as well as general outlooks on economic trends, interest rates, and exchange rates – but also on investors’ individual investment goals, financial situations, and personal preferences.

But what investment strategies are actually available? How do I ensure sufficient diversification? And how can I capitalise on opportunities and limit risks?

In this guide, we answer these questions, explain the main investment strategies and their characteristics, and outline what to consider before buying your first ETF shares.

The essentials in brief:
What are investment strategies?

  • Definition: An investment strategy describes the approach to buying and selling – for example, stocks or ETFs – with the goal of achieving the most profitable investment results possible.

  • Investment Styles: Your investment style helps determine which ETF investment strategy is appropriate. Investment styles are generally divided into conservative, balanced and speculative.

  • Investment Strategies: Examples of strategies that investors can pursue using ETFs include the value strategy and the rebalancing strategy. These can be implemented, for example, through a regular ETF investment plan or an ETF portfolio.

  • Selection: The selection of ETFs should be based on your savings goals and risk tolerance. Once you have clearly defined your strategy before investing, stick to it throughout the investment period.

Advert
Get started with ETF investing

Find and compare thousands of ETFs. Use powerful filters, detailed analytics, and independent data to discover the right ETF for your portfolio.

What is an investment strategy for ETFs?

An investment strategy is a targeted, long-term approach to buying and selling stocks, ETFs, bonds or other securities, aimed at achieving the best possible investment results.

Investment strategies using ETFs are based not only on objective criteria – such as fundamental and technical analysis of securities, as well as general outlooks on economic trends, interest rates, and exchange rates – but also on the investor’s financial situation and personal preferences.

A sound and well-founded ETF investment strategy takes the following into account:

  • Financial goals
  • Risk tolerance
  • Existing assets
  • Life circumstances
  • Future financial needs

Since all these factors and preferences can vary from person to person, there is no single ETF investment strategy that is best for every investor or guarantees the highest return.

In a narrower sense, an investment strategy also refers to the approach taken when investing in stocks – that is, the rules governing when, how, and in which companies to invest. Some approaches are similar, but most differ considerably, and some strategies can be combined. It is advisable to think about your approach early on, ideally before making your first investment. This helps you avoid mistakes in your ETF investment strategy from the outset.

What investment styles are there?

Investment StyleInvestment HorizonInvestment Risk
ConservativeMostly long-termLow
BalancedMedium-term to long-termModerate
SpeculativeMore short-termHigh
Source: extraETF Research, as of 11/2022

There are typically three different investment styles: conservative, balanced, and speculative. These are closely linked to the investment horizon – that is, the planned duration of the actual investment. They also differ significantly in terms of the weighting of the various asset classes in which they invest. Before implementing a specific ETF investment strategy, investors should therefore consider which investment style suits them and what their risk tolerance is.

What investment strategies are available with ETFs?

There are many ETF investment strategies. Some focus on particular securities or indices, while others differ in their structure, underlying assumptions and approach. All of them, however, aim to maximise returns.

Here is a brief overview of the most important ETF investment strategies:

Thanks to this variety of approaches, everyone can invest according to their personal preferences. Note, however, that not every strategy works in every market phase.

The table below shows examples of strategies that may suit investors, depending on their risk tolerance:

Investor TypeInvestment Strategies
Low risk tolerance
  • Value and dividend strategies
  • Large-caps
  • Core-satellite strategy
Moderate risk tolerance
  • Value and dividend strategies
  • Core-satellite strategy
  • Mid- and small-caps
High risk tolerance
  • Growth strategy
  • Trend-following strategy
  • Small-caps
Source: extraETF Research, as of 09/2022

The chart below compares the relative performance over time of ETFs that follow different investment strategies, with an ETF tracking the MSCI World Index as a benchmark.

Chart comparing the performance of ETFs that follow different investment strategies
Source: extraETF Research, as of 09/2022

The ETFs shown have performed quite differently: depending on the product and its strategy, they have either outperformed or underperformed the MSCI World ETF. Note, however, that a strategy’s better or worse past performance says nothing about its quality or its future performance. This applies particularly to ETFs that have beaten the benchmark: there is no guarantee they will keep doing so, and higher potential returns usually come with higher risks.

Stick to your ETF investment strategy consistently over the long term

Martin Vogt, extraETFMartin Vogt, Education & Content Manager
Before investing in ETFs, take the time to clearly define your savings goals. From there, you can develop a suitable, long-term and broadly diversified ETF investment strategy and follow it consistently towards your goals. It can help you avoid panicking during turbulent times in the stock market and stay the course.
Martin Vogt, Education & Content Manager

What does "willingness to take risks" mean?

Risk tolerance is a person’s willingness to take risks when investing. It is subjective and shaped by personal experience and knowledge of managing money. Three investment styles are generally distinguished. All include stocks as an asset class, so they also apply to equity ETFs and equity funds. Further distinctions based on individual preferences are, of course, possible:

How do I find the right investment strategy?

There are many investment strategies, but none meets every need and expectation. The best strategy is the one that fits your risk profile and personal needs. These six questions will help you decide which strategies are right for you.

Join the extraETF community

Werde Teil der extraETF Community

Explore the world of ETFs and make informed investment decisions.

  • Find ETFs that match your criteria with our ETF Search.
  • Compare costs, performance, and risk side by side.
  • Save your favourites to a watchlist and receive price alerts.
  • Explore detailed ETF profiles with key metrics and holdings.

Which asset classes can I use to implement my investment strategy?

Asset classes offer different potential returns, and their risks vary too. Before investing, make sure you thoroughly understand your chosen investment strategy, the investment options, the opportunities and risks, and the asset classes involved.

Asset ClassType of InvestmentRiskOpportunity
LiquidityCurrent account, easy-access savings accountLowLow
StocksStocks, funds, ETFsHighHigh
BondsBonds, funds, ETFsMediumMedium
PropertyProperty, REITs, ETFs, fundsMediumMedium
CommoditiesPhysical commodities, funds, ETFsHighHigh
Alternative InvestmentsPrivate equity, art, cryptoMediumMedium
Source: extraETF Research, as of 11/2022

When choosing an asset allocation for your own investment strategy, consider how individual asset classes may interact. Combining several asset classes can not only improve diversification but also affect the volatility of the whole portfolio. Each asset class also has its own characteristics, and trading options and costs may vary.

Conclusion:
What is the best investment strategy for ETFs?

There is no single best investment strategy for ETFs, as investors differ in their goals, life situations, risk profiles and investment horizons. In addition, there is a wide variety of ETF investment strategies, which are hotly debated among experts and often rest on conflicting concepts and assumptions. Investments can generally be made through a regular ETF investment plan or a one-off ETF investment.

Diversification can be a key factor when selecting ETFs for your investment strategy, as it spreads risk more widely and can reduce a portfolio’s volatility. Adding different asset classes can also strengthen your strategy, but each has its own characteristics, opportunities and risks, so research them thoroughly before investing. Investors can also use ETF recommendation lists to get an overview.

Finally, you can manage, analyse and monitor your portfolio, based on your chosen investment strategy, using a portfolio tracking tool. This lets you, among other things, compare the performance of different portfolios and ETF investment strategies, making it possible, for example, to identify performance differences or spot potential concentration risks early.

Frequently Asked Questions About Investment Strategies Using ETFs