Smart beta ETFs

Smart beta ETFs combine passive and active elements to optimize the risk/return profile. They use various factors such as value, size, quality, momentum and volatility. Find the best smart beta ETFs here!

How do smart beta ETFs work?

Optimized investment strategies for better returns


With ETFs that use traditional market-cap weighting, investors are investing in the world’s largest companies. This means that a single ETF already covers a large portion of the market capitalization of the respective investment region. One drawback of this, however, is that the largest companies in the index are weighted disproportionately heavily. And these are often stocks that have already performed well in the past. Alternative weighting methods aim to avoid these drawbacks. They use different weighting criteria to either generate excess returns or minimize risk.

Smart beta ETFs, also known as strategic beta or factor ETFs, aim to outperform the market or better manage risk. Discover how these ETFs work and what types of smart beta ETFs are available.

The essentials in brief:
Understanding Smart Beta ETFs

  • Definition: Smart-beta ETFs use specific factors such as value, size, quality, momentum, and volatility to optimize performance.

  • Advantages: Better risk diversification and potentially higher risk-adjusted returns at lower costs compared to actively managed funds.

  • Disadvantages: Complexity and potentially increased volatility, depending on the factor strategies selected.

  • Suitability: Suitable for investors with a higher risk tolerance who are willing to accept the additional complexities and volatility.

Explanation: What are smart beta ETFs?

Smart-beta ETFs are exchange-traded funds that enhance traditional index investing by applying alternative weighting strategies. These funds follow a rule-based approach that combines elements of active and passive investing. The goal is to outperform the market or better manage risk. By focusing on specific factors such as value, size, quality, momentum, and volatility, smart-beta ETFs offer investors the opportunity to benefit from specific market anomalies and potentially achieve higher risk-adjusted returns.

Investors should keep the following in mind when using smart-beta ETFs: While factors can often generate higher returns over extended periods than investing in the broader market, However, there are also periods in which individual factors underperform. It is difficult to predict which factor will be appropriate during which market phase.

Did you know?
Background: The history of smart beta ETFs

More than 50 years ago, financial researchers were already exploring alternative weighting methods. Key milestones in this research included the Capital Asset Pricing Model (CAPM) developed by William Sharpe, as well as the three-factor model by Eugene Fama and Kenneth French, which demonstrated for the first time on a scientific basis that excess returns could be achieved for the value and size factors (companies with smaller market capitalization).

Thanks to ever-improving data analysis capabilities, up to 600 factors can now be found in the pseudoscientific literature, the majority of which have no causal relationships whatsoever. Not even a handful of factors have been scientifically proven to have a lasting impact on returns or risk.

What smart beta strategies are there?

Join the extraETF community

Werde Teil der extraETF Community

Explore the world of ETFs and make informed investment decisions.

  • Find ETFs that match your criteria with our ETF Search.
  • Compare costs, performance, and risk side by side.
  • Save your favourites to a watchlist and receive price alerts.
  • Explore detailed ETF profiles with key metrics and holdings.

When does which smart beta strategy pay off?

A smart-beta strategy does not always outperform the underlying benchmark index. The following table shows how factors respond to different phases of GDP growth over extended periods.

Outperformance during strong economic growthOutperformance during periods of weak economic growth
Equal WeightedDividend
MomentumQuality
ValueLow Volatility
Size 
Source: extraETF Research, as of July 2024

 

The right strategy for every stock market phase

markus-jordan-review-extraetf.pngMarkus Jordan, founder of extraETF
Not every factor works in every stock market phase, and a lower return may also be possible. For example, some factors are more suitable in phases of economic recovery or boom, while others are more suitable in a downturn or recession. It is therefore not easy for private investors to focus on the most attractive factor in each case. Multi-factor ETFs, which focus on various equity factors, offer a remedy here.
Markus Jordan, founder of extraETF

Advantages of smart beta ETFs

  • Targeted factor strategies: Smart-beta ETFs utilize specific factors such as value, size, quality, momentum, and volatility to enhance performance and manage risk.
  • Better risk diversification: By diversifying across various factors, smart-beta ETFs can spread risk more effectively than traditional index funds.
  • Cost efficiency: Although they employ a more active management strategy, the costs of smart-beta ETFs are generally lower than those of actively managed funds.
  • Transparency & rule-based approach: The selection and weighting of stocks are based on clearly defined rules, ensuring transparency and traceability.

Disadvantages of smart beta ETFs

  • Complexity: The underlying strategies and factors may be difficult for inexperienced investors to understand and track.
  • No guarantee of outperformance: Despite the use of specific factors, there is no guarantee that smart-beta ETFs will consistently outperform the market.
  • Increased volatility: Depending on the factors selected, smart-beta ETFs may exhibit more volatile performance, particularly during turbulent market periods.
  • Deviation from the benchmark index: Since smart-beta ETFs use alternative weighting strategies, they may deviate significantly from traditional benchmark indices, resulting in different returns.

We answer your questions about smart beta ETFs

Affiliate notice *
Links marked with an asterisk (*) are advertising or affiliate links. If you purchase or sign up through this link, we receive compensation from the provider. This comes at no additional cost or disadvantage to you. We use this revenue to fund our free services. Thank you for your support.