The 4 Per cent Rule

Achieve Financial Freedom with This Withdrawal Strategy


Anyone who wants to live off their assets and achieve financial freedom will sooner or later come across the 4% rule. It promises to preserve your capital for life while allowing for regular withdrawals. But what’s the deal with it – and does the method really work?

In this guide, we’ll explore the background of the 4% rule, explain how to apply it and its limitations, and show you how to integrate it into your retirement planning and financial strategy.

The essentials in brief:
All About the 4 Per cent Rule

  • The 4 Per cent Rule: The 4 Per cent Rule states that, with an annual withdrawal rate of 4 per cent, one’s assets will not be depleted. Other sources emphasise that, under this rule, the capital is subject to only a low probability of depletion for at least 30 years.

  • Capital base: This is calculated as 25 times the amount of annual expenditures (the "25-fold rule").

  • Assumed rate of return: The method assumes long-term stable returns of over 4 per cent.

  • Points of criticism: Tax burden, market conditions, and the risk associated with the order of returns are often overlooked.

  • Target audience: This method is particularly relevant for people seeking financial independence, those who follow a frugal lifestyle, or those aiming to retire early.

  • Note: The statutory pension and dividends can be factored in as supplementary income.

Advert
Get started with ETF investing

Find and compare thousands of ETFs. Use powerful filters, detailed analytics, and independent data to discover the right ETF for your portfolio.

Definition: What is the 4 per cent rule?

The 4% Rule (also known as the Bengen Rule) is a withdrawal strategy and a rule of thumb. It was developed in the 1990s by U.S. financial advisor William Bengen. It is based on historical calculations of returns on stocks and bonds in the U.S. and was later confirmed by the Trinity Study. The goal was to determine a reliable withdrawal rate that would allow investors to use their assets for 30 years without depleting them.

The principle is simple: In the first year, you withdraw 4 per cent of your initial capital and adjust this amount for inflation when making withdrawals in subsequent years. This allows you to maintain a constant, inflation-adjusted standard of living – at least in theory.

Usage: How does the 4 per cent rule work?

The 4 per cent rule is based on 25 times your annual expenses. Using the 25x rule, you multiply this amount by 25 to determine your starting capital for financial freedom. The result is the amount from which you can withdraw 4 per cent annually.

Note: The 4 per cent rule is only a rule of thumb for general guidance; it does not take into account important factors such as taxes, inflation, and investment costs.

Example: How to Apply the 4 Per cent Rule

Willi has monthly expenses of £1,500. As a frugalist, he wants to build up a nest egg and invest for the long term so he can live off it. To calculate his annual expenses, he multiplies £1,500 by 12 to get his annual expenses.

Annual expenses = Monthly expenses (£1,500) × 12 months = £18,000

Willi’s annual expenses come to £18,000. To calculate the capital he needs, he multiplies his annual expenses by 25.

Required capital = Annual expenses (18,000) × 25 = £450,000

Willi should have this capital at the start of the withdrawal phase in order to be able to withdraw £18,000 annually over a period of 30 years without depleting his principal. However, Willi also knows that this is only a rough guide, and because of many unaccounted-for factors – such as taxes, inflation, or investment costs – he prefers to calculate using a much more conservative withdrawal rate of 3 per cent and to have an emergency fund on hand as well.

Join the extraETF community

Werde Teil der extraETF Community

Explore the world of ETFs and make informed investment decisions.

  • Find ETFs that match your criteria with our ETF Search.
  • Compare costs, performance, and risk side by side.
  • Save your favourites to a watchlist and receive price alerts.
  • Explore detailed ETF profiles with key metrics and holdings.

Prerequisites: When does the 4 per cent rule work?

For the 4% rule to work, certain conditions must be met.

  • Real Return: The 4% rule assumes that your portfolio will generate a real return of at least 4% over the long term.
  • Inflation adjustment: Annual withdrawals must be adjusted for inflation to maintain purchasing power.
  • Taxes: The 4% rule does not account for tax deductions, so actual net withdrawals will be lower.
  • Savings Rate: To build up the necessary capital, a high savings rate is required – often 20 to 30 per cent of net income.
  • Capital base: You need 25 times your planned annual expenses as starting capital for this strategy.
  • Discipline: The strategy requires consistent implementation. Even in years when the stock market performs poorly, you must not sell out of panic.
  • Flexibility: Those who can adjust their spending as needed increase the viability of the withdrawal plan.

Tip: extraETF’s financial calculators are handy tools that do more than just help you plan withdrawals. They also include calculators for saving, personal financial planning, returns, interest rates, taxes, and many other aspects of investing and personal finance.

Criticism of the 4-Per cent Rule

There are several problems with applying the 4 per cent rule in practice:

  1. Sequence-of-returns risk: If a stock market crash, a sharp correction, or a bear market occurs right at the start of retirement, the early depletion of capital can damage your wealth over the long term.
  2. Taxes and Fees: Tax burdens such as the flat-rate withholding tax, fees for investment products, or investment account fees are often overlooked. As a result, real net withdrawals are often lower than the gross amount. Taxes and fees may also be subject to change.
  3. Inflation: If the inflation rate rises, the withdrawal amount increases because the required rate of return also rises.
  4. Longevity risk: If you live longer than expected, you may find that your capital has been depleted too soon. This is particularly problematic for frugalists or FIRE advocates who retire at age 40 or 50.
  5. Market fluctuations: The stock market is volatile. Losses in stock prices, especially at the beginning of the withdrawal phase, can jeopardize your withdrawal strategy.
  6. Withdrawal Period: The rule is based on a maximum withdrawal period of 30 years. If you retire earlier, the period is therefore often calculated to be too short.
  7. Fees: Custody and transaction costs are not factored into the 4% rule, but they do reduce your returns.
  8. Health and Long-Term Care Insurance: You’ll have to cover these costs yourself in retirement, which puts an additional strain on your disposable income.
  9. Unforeseen Expenses: The rule of thumb does not account for unexpected expenses, which is why having an additional nest egg is essential.

Alternatives to the Classic 4% Rule

Fixed withdrawal rate with no risk

Simple withdrawal without investment (e.g., via a money market account): no fluctuations, but low payouts.

Fixed withdrawal rate with risk

Annual withdrawals of 3–4 per cent from an invested portfolio. The higher the equity allocation, the higher the potential return – but also the higher the risk and volatility.

Flexible withdrawal rate

The withdrawal rate is adjusted annually based on the portfolio’s value. Advantage: Lower risk of financial ruin. Disadvantage: Fluctuating standard of living.

Tip: You can find an overview of the different types of withdrawal strategies in our guide on this topic.

Tips for Applying the 4 Per cent Rule

Plan generously and factor in a longer withdrawal period (e.g., 35–40 years), especially if you plan to retire early.

  • Diversify: A sufficiently broad, globally diversified ETF portfolio or a global equity ETF reduces risk more effectively than investments with concentrated risk, such as individual stocks or country-specific ETFs.
  • Fact in taxes: Use tax calculators to account for capital gains tax and the solidarity surcharge, for example.
  • Stay flexible: Adjust your withdrawal plan as needed to account for new market conditions or life circumstances.
  • Take the statutory pension into account: Factor in the statutory pension, as it reduces the actual amount you’ll need to withdraw from your capital during retirement and thus increases the reliability of your financial plan.
  • Keep an emergency fund on hand: Also, keep an emergency fund available. For unplanned expenses, you should maintain a separate liquidity buffer outside your withdrawal portfolio.
  • Choose a conservative withdrawal rate: If you want more security, reduce the withdrawal rate to 3 per cent or less. It’s better to calculate generously, for example, by assuming a longer time horizon or higher capital requirements.

Conclusion:
Who is the 4 per cent rule suitable for?

The 4 per cent rule is a useful concept for planning financial independence. It is particularly well-suited as a rough guideline and a rule of thumb in long-term financial planning. However, those who prioritize greater security or anticipate a long retirement should calculate using a lower withdrawal rate (for example, 3 per cent) or consider more flexible withdrawal strategies. Always keep in mind factors that are often overlooked in such rough guidelines but can have a major impact and are subject to change, such as taxes, fees, inflation, and expenses.

If you want to take control of your own retirement, the 4% rule can make the first step easier, even though it’s not a guarantee. Other tools, such as the extraETF withdrawal calculator, can help you make informed decisions about depleting your savings and making withdrawals, as well as run through various scenarios.

Frequently Asked Questions About the 4% Rule

Risk Disclosure: The information and representations contained in this article have been prepared to the best of our knowledge and belief. No warranty is given as to their accuracy or completeness. The content is not a substitute for tax and/or legal advice. The content does not constitute such advice and cannot serve as a substitute for it. Therefore, any liability or claims of any kind are excluded.