What Is an ETC?

How can you trade exchange-traded commodities?


A well-balanced portfolio includes stocks, bonds and commodities. Investors can gain easy, low-cost exposure to the first two asset classes using exchange-traded funds (ETFs), but for commodities such as precious metals they need exchange-traded commodities (ETCs). ETCs may be less well known than ETFs, but they are just as easy to trade on the stock exchange.

So what are ETCs? How can you invest in them? How are they backed? This guide answers these questions and more.

The essentials in brief:
Everything You Need to Know About Investing in ETCs at a Glance

  • Definition: ETCs are exchange-traded securities that give investors exposure to commodities. They are debt securities, a special type of certificate.

  • Distinction from ETFs: The main difference is legal: ETCs are classified as debt securities, whereas ETFs are structured as segregated funds.

  • Risk: Unlike ETFs, ETCs carry issuer risk. If the issuer becomes insolvent, investors may lose some or all of their capital.

  • Collateralisation: To reduce issuer risk, ETC debt securities are usually backed by additional collateral. There are three types: physical, full and third-party collateralisation.

Advert
Get started with ETF investing

Find and compare thousands of ETFs. Use powerful filters, detailed analytics, and independent data to discover the right ETF for your portfolio.

Definition: What is an ETC?

An ETC (exchange-traded commodity) is a security traded on a stock exchange that gives investors exposure to commodities. ETCs are similar to ETFs but specialise in commodities. These include precious metals, agricultural products and energy commodities traded on commodity exchanges. ETCs track the performance of an underlying commodity or commodity index. Investors can invest in ETCs through their bank or broker.

ETCs offer broadly the same advantages as exchange-traded funds (ETFs). They are more cost-effective than traditional stocks or funds and highly transparent. They also have no fixed term, trade continuously on the stock exchange and offer high liquidity.

The only significant difference between ETCs and ETFs is their legal structure. ETFs are segregated funds, so the ETF provider is legally required to post certain collateral to minimise the risk of default in the event of insolvency. For investors, this means there is no issuer risk with ETFs.

In contrast, ETCs are perpetual debt securities for which the issuer is liable. In many cases, however, the issuer invests the money directly in the underlying commodities (physical backing). This is usually the case for commodities with low storage costs, such as gold or copper. In other cases, other safeguards protect investors’ assets, so the default risk is relatively low.

Common uses of ETCs include investing in gold and investing in commodities. ETCs let investors gain exposure to commodity prices without owning the physical commodities, offering a flexible and liquid way into the commodities market.

What is the difference between ETCs and ETFs?

ETFs are passive, exchange-traded funds that track an underlying index. In contrast, ETCs track the price movements of commodities via a commodity index. These include precious metals such as gold and silver, agricultural commodities such as corn and wheat, and other commodities. The main difference is that ETCs are legally structured as debt securities, while ETFs are investment funds.

The differences lie in the details. An ETF is subject to legal requirements, and if the ETF provider becomes insolvent, the fund’s assets are protected from creditors’ claims. The risk to investors is therefore minimal.

Because ETCs are legally classified as debt securities, investors are always exposed to issuer risk – the risk that the issuer becomes insolvent. This risk is typically mitigated by additional collateral, but the nature of that collateral varies significantly.

Join the extraETF community

Werde Teil der extraETF Community

Explore the world of ETFs and make informed investment decisions.

  • Find ETFs that match your criteria with our ETF Search.
  • Compare costs, performance, and risk side by side.
  • Save your favourites to a watchlist and receive price alerts.
  • Explore detailed ETF profiles with key metrics and holdings.

The Collateralization of ETCs

Investors who wish to invest in ETCs should be familiar with the following three types of collateral:

  • Physically backed ETCs
  • Fully collateralised ETCs
  • ETCs with third-party collateral

ETC providers use these methods, which we examine in more detail below, to minimise issuer risk.

Physically backed ETCs

ETCs on commodities such as industrial metals (aluminium, copper and zinc) or precious metals (gold, silver and platinum) can be physically backed. These ETCs track the market price more or less exactly and deliver similar returns. For example, if you invest in a physically backed gold ETC, you can assume that gold bars worth exactly the amount invested are held in the trustee’s vault. Issuer risk can thus be ruled out.

Fully collateralised ETCs

Fully collateralised ETCs are also backed by collateral. However, this collateral is not physical commodities but standard loans granted by entities such as insurance companies. The collateral consists of either cash deposits from financial institutions or high-quality securities.

ETCs with third-party collateral

Third-party collateralisation applies when a third party bears the issuer risk. This can be a financial institution or another company that is liable with its corporate assets if the issuer defaults. For example, various ETCs on commodities such as oil are backed by prominent energy companies, which are liable with their operating assets.

What are the risks associated with ETCs?

Investing in ETCs involves the following risks in particular:

  • Issuer risk
  • Price fluctuation risk
  • Currency risk

Since ETCs are legally classified as debt securities, investors should first consider issuer risk. If the issuer of the ETC defaults due to insolvency, there is a risk of losing the invested money – unlike with ETFs, which are investment funds. Investors must keep an eye on the issuer’s creditworthiness. ETCs also carry price fluctuation risk and currency risk, which we look at more closely below.

Issuer Risk

Issuer risk is the risk that the issuer of a security, such as an ETC, can no longer meet its payment obligations, for example because of insolvency. Bonds and other debt securities can be affected too. Possible consequences include payment deferrals, incomplete interest payments or only partial redemptions. Investors must therefore be prepared to lose some or all of their investment.

Price Fluctuation Risk

ETCs track the performance of the underlying asset, i.e. the commodity. Investors are therefore exposed to price fluctuation risk, also known as market risk: if the price of the tracked commodity falls, the ETC loses value; if it rises, the ETC gains. This risk also applies when trading other securities on the stock exchange, such as stocks or bonds.

Currency Risk

Currency risk is another risk associated with ETCs. Commodities and precious metals are rarely priced in pounds; the US dollar dominates. The performance of an investment with foreign currency exposure may therefore depend on exchange rate movements. Some ETCs, however, offer currency hedging.

Investing in commodities through ETCs can increase the diversification of your portfolio

markus-jordan-review-extraetf.pngMarkus Jordan, Founder of extraETF
Alongside stocks and bonds, commodities are a key component of a well-balanced portfolio. ETCs offer a cost-effective, straightforward way to add this asset class.
Markus Jordan, Founder of extraETF

What are the benefits of ETCs?

Investing in ETCs offers many of the same advantages as investing in exchange-traded funds (ETFs). ETCs can help investors diversify, giving them easy access to commodities, favourable pricing and transparency. In addition, ETCs have no fixed term, trade continuously on the stock exchange and offer high liquidity.

How much do ETCs cost?

ETC fees typically range from 0.00 to 0.59 per cent per year. This total expense ratio includes costs such as custody and management fees, as well as insurance premiums. Additional costs may apply for account custody, dealing and currency hedging.

Conclusion:
ETCs as a Flexible Addition to an Investment Portfolio

Investing in ETCs is a convenient, cost-effective and transparent way to add commodities to your portfolio alongside other asset classes. ETCs can serve as a useful additional component of your asset allocation.

ETCs are linked to the performance of an underlying commodity, such as industrial or precious metals, energy or agricultural products. Unlike popular ETFs, ETCs are not investment funds but debt securities. Investors must therefore consider not only price fluctuation risk and currency risk but also issuer risk, and keep a close eye on the issuer’s creditworthiness. Because ETCs are traded daily on the stock exchange, you do not need a specialist ETC broker.

We'll answer any other questions you may have about ETCs