Gold ETFs and gold ETCs

Investing in gold is considered by many to be the safe haven par excellence. But what is the best way to invest in gold?

Key highlights

Facts about Gold ETFs and gold ETCs
TER:
0.11 % - 0.54 %
Volume:
£95.58B
Provider:
7
Available ETFs:
14

Price development

Chart of the Gold ETFs and gold ETCs

Performance

Return of the Gold ETFs and gold ETCs
YTD:
-8.93 %
1 year:
-2.77 %
3 years:
+87.14 %
5 years:
+108.01 %
Markus Jordan, Founder & CEO extraETF
Gold ETFs and gold ETCs - simply buy gold into your investment account
Markus Jordan, Founder & CEO extraETF

Investing in gold ETFs and gold ETCs

What is the best way to invest in gold?


Gold ETFs and gold ETCs offer investors a simple and efficient way to invest in gold as a commodity. These types of securities allow investors to profit from changes in the price of the precious metal without owning physical gold. Due to their high liquidity and transparency, gold ETFs and gold ETCs are attractive to both retail and institutional investors.

In this guide, you’ll learn how to find the best gold ETF or gold ETC for your investment needs, why this investment vehicle can be a good choice, and what advantages and disadvantages it entails.

Facts about gold

Elements:

Au

State of matter:

solid

Application:

Industry, Jewelry, Investments

Produktion:

Schürfen

Source: extraETF, data as of: 5 Jun 2024

Advert
Discover the right ETFs for your investment strategy

Explore a wide range of ETFs across different themes, markets, and investment strategies. Whether you’re looking to diversify your portfolio or invest in specific trends, find the right ETFs in just a few clicks.

Do gold ETFs or gold ETCs make sense?

Gold is a shiny, yellowish precious metal that is used as a store of value and a medium of exchange, and is crafted into jewelry. It is indestructible yet malleable. The value of gold is recognized and appreciated worldwide. Another positive characteristic is its high electrical and thermal conductivity, meaning that gold not only serves as an investment but can also be used in industry, where it is sometimes alloyed with other metals.

There are various ways to participate in the performance and appreciation of the gold price. 

  • Physical purchase of gold bars (starting at 1 gram)
  • Physical purchase of coins (e.g., Krugerrand)
  • Gold ETFs or gold ETCs
  • Gold mining stocks (e.g., Barrick Gold)
  • Gold mining ETFs

However, gold mining stocks and gold mining ETFs are significantly riskier than an investment in physical gold or an exchange-traded gold product.

Gold ETFs and gold ETCs offer a flexible and cost-effective way to invest in gold. They allow investors to participate in the performance of the precious metal without having to deal with the complexity of physically purchasing and storing gold.

Especially in times of economic uncertainty and inflation, gold can be attractive as a store of value and a hedge against loss of purchasing power. Gold ETCs or gold ETFs can also make sense as a component of a retirement portfolio. Gold ETFs and gold ETCs also have the advantage of being easily tradable and available on regulated markets. However, they are not risk-free; in particular, the price of gold can fluctuate significantly, which can lead to substantial losses in value.

Overall, gold ETFs and gold ETCs are a sensible addition to a portfolio, particularly for diversification and as a hedge against economic crises.

What is the difference between a gold ETF and a gold ETC?

The main difference between a gold ETF and a gold ETC lies in their legal structure and the type of collateralization. Many investors looking to invest in gold seek out a gold ETF. Under UCITS regulations, however, it is not permitted for an investment fund to invest exclusively in a single commodity. For this reason, while there are broadly diversified commodity ETFs that invest in various commodities, there are no specific gold ETFs. 

Investors who want to invest specifically in gold must therefore turn to gold ETCs (Exchange Traded Commodities). 

Gold ETCs are debt securities that track the price of gold, whereas gold ETFs represent shares in a fund that holds physical gold. Since the issuance of gold ETFs is not legally possible in Germany, gold ETCs backed by physical gold are an attractive alternative that offer a similarly high level of security as gold ETFs.

Here are the key differences between gold ETFs and gold ETCs:

CriterionGold ETFGold ETC
Legal structureInvestment fund, regulated by UCITS directivesDebt instrument, not regulated by UCITS
Coverage / CollateralPhysically backed by gold May be physically backed by gold, but also by other financial instruments (futures)
RiskLower risk, as it is backed by gold and regulated Higher risk due to issuer risk
Trading / LiquidityHigh liquidity, traded on the stock exchange like a stockMay have lower liquidity, also traded on the stock exchange
Investor protectionHigh protection, secured by the fund structure in the event of insolvencyLess protection, dependent on the issuer’s creditworthiness and physical storage of gold

What are physically backed gold ETCs?

Physically backed gold ETCs are exchange-traded securities (ETCs) that are backed by physical gold. With these ETCs, the provider stores the gold holdings, usually in the form of gold bars, in a vault. 

A key advantage of these physically backed gold ETCs is the right to physical delivery of the gold: Investors have the option to exchange their shares for physical gold and have it delivered to their home or pick it up at a collection point.

Examples of physically backed gold ETCs with a right to physical delivery include Xetra-Gold and EUWAX Gold II, where one gram of gold is held in reserve for each share certificate and physical delivery is possible. However, there are also physically backed gold ETCs without a right to physical delivery, such as the Invesco Physical Gold ETC.

Gold ETCs in comparison

When comparing gold ETCs, factors such as the total expense ratio (TER), liquidity, the type of custody (physical vs. synthetic), and the option for physical delivery should be taken into account.

The information in the following table answers these and other questions to help you make an informed decision.

Performance comparison of the best gold ETCs

The performance of gold ETCs depends heavily on the movements of the gold price and the U.S. dollar. However, differences in costs and tracking accuracy can lead to slight variations in returns. Historical performance data should therefore be reviewed regularly to identify the best gold ETC.

Note: Past performance is no guarantee of future results.

A comparison of the largest gold ETCs

Here you’ll find a comparison of the largest gold ETCs. An ETC should have assets under management of at least 100 million euros to be profitable for the ETC provider. This reduces your risk of the ETC being closed. The largest gold ETCs by assets under management include:

Join the extraETF community

Werde Teil der extraETF Community

Explore the world of ETFs and make informed investment decisions.

  • Find ETFs that match your criteria with our ETF Search.
  • Compare costs, performance, and risk side by side.
  • Save your favourites to a watchlist and receive price alerts.
  • Explore detailed ETF profiles with key metrics and holdings.

Which is the cheapest gold ETC?

The most cost-effective gold ETCs are characterized by low total expense ratios (TER). Here you’ll find a comparison of the most cost-effective gold ETCs. Be sure to consider the total costs of ETFs.

Advantages of gold ETCs

We’ve summarized the key benefits of gold ETCs for you here. Here are the points you need to keep in mind.

  • Easy investment: Gold ETCs provide easy access to gold investments without the need for physical storage.
  • Liquidity: Tradable on exchanges like stocks, which allows for quick buying and selling decisions.
  • Low costs: Compared to physically owning gold, gold ETCs incur only minimal storage and insurance costs.
  • Security: The gold invested in gold ETCs is stored in secure vaults. This reduces the risk of theft.

Disadvantages of gold ETCs

We’ve summarized the main drawbacks of gold ETCs here. These are the points you need to keep in mind.

  • No physical ownership: Investors do not own physical gold, but only a security that tracks the price of gold.
  • Price risk: Gold ETCs are exposed to the risk of price volatility in the gold market. Minor deviations between the ETC price and the actual gold price are possible.
  • Currency risk: Gold ETCs denominated in foreign currencies carry an additional currency risk.
  • Costs: Management fees can affect returns over the long term.
  • No physical delivery: Not all gold ETCs offer the option to receive physical gold.

Gold mining shares - an alternative to gold ETFs?

Gold mining stocks and gold mining ETFs offer an alternative to gold ETFs, as they provide the opportunity to benefit from leverage on the price of gold. Unlike gold ETFs, which directly track the price of gold, gold mining stocks are shares of companies that mine and produce gold. These companies can benefit disproportionately from a rising gold price, making the stocks potentially more lucrative. In addition, some gold mining companies offer dividends, which provide an additional source of income. Gold mining ETFs bundle various gold mining stocks into a single ETF, significantly reducing the risk associated with a single stock. Here you’ll find the best gold mining ETFs.

However, gold mining stocks also come with higher risks. In addition to gold price risk, they are subject to company-specific risks such as production outages, management decisions, and geopolitical uncertainties in the producing countries. These factors can strongly influence the performance of the stocks and make them more volatile than direct investments in gold via ETFs.

In comparison, gold ETFs and gold ETCs offer a more stable and lower-risk investment vehicle, as they directly track the price of gold and do not involve company-specific risks. Furthermore, gold ETCs—particularly physically backed gold ETCs—offer tax advantages that are not available with gold mining stocks.

Conclusion:
This is the best gold ETC

The best gold ETC is the one that best suits the investor’s investment strategy and financial situation. Leading gold ETCs include physically backed products such as Xetra-Gold and EUWAX Gold II, which are backed by real gold bars and offer investors the option to have the gold physically delivered to them if needed.

Another important factor when choosing the best gold ETCs is cost. Cost-effective options such as the Invesco Physical Gold ETC and the iShares Physical Gold ETC are characterized by a low total expense ratio (TER) while offering an exact tracking of the gold price. These factors make them attractive alternatives for investors who wish to invest in gold cost-effectively.

Which gold ETC is best for you depends on your individual needs. When making your selection, you should consider factors such as costs and the option for physical delivery.

Frequently asked questions about gold ETCs

Affiliate notice *
Links marked with an asterisk (*) are advertising or affiliate links. If you purchase or sign up through this link, we receive compensation from the provider. This comes at no additional cost or disadvantage to you. We use this revenue to fund our free services. Thank you for your support.

This information might also interest you