Choosing Crypto ETPs: Tips and Tricks

What criteria should be considered when selecting a crypto ETP?


Crypto ETPs are a simple, secure alternative for investors who would rather not buy cryptocurrencies through an unregulated online exchange.

However, providers differ. With so many products on offer, it is worth examining the features and terms of the available crypto ETPs closely to find one that suits your needs.

Here is what to consider when investing in crypto ETPs.

The essentials in brief:
Things to Keep in Mind When Choosing Crypto ETPs

  • A Secure Alternative Without a Wallet: Crypto ETPs offer a simple, secure way to invest in cryptocurrencies without a wallet or cumbersome access keys. You can buy them directly on regulated exchanges.

  • Regulation and Oversight: Authorisation and the regulator play a crucial role. The European Union is considered a leader in cryptocurrency regulation, and investors should check that the crypto ETP is authorised by a recognised financial regulator.

  • Physical Custody and Delivery Option: How the cryptocurrency is held in physical custody affects issuer risk. Investors should also check whether a delivery option is available, as this can bring tax advantages in some countries.

  • Keeping an Eye on Costs: Costs are crucial when selecting a crypto ETP. The total expense ratio (TER) shows the total annual cost. Investors should weigh this against the expected return.

Advert
Get started with ETF investing

Find and compare thousands of ETFs. Use powerful filters, detailed analytics, and independent data to discover the right ETF for your portfolio.

Crypto ETPs – the Safe Alternative to Buying Cryptocurrencies

Crypto ETPs are a safe and simple way to invest in cryptocurrencies. Investors don’t need a wallet or cumbersome access keys, and they needn’t worry about hacker attacks or the collapse of unregulated trading platforms. Even so, they gain exposure to Bitcoin, Ether and other cryptocurrencies.

Crypto ETPs are easy to use. Investors simply need an investment account with a bank or broker, and can then buy the products on regulated exchanges such as Xetra in Germany using the product’s ISIN. In this respect, crypto ETPs are similar to traditional ETFs or funds.

Join the extraETF community

Werde Teil der extraETF Community

Explore the world of ETFs and make informed investment decisions.

  • Find ETFs that match your criteria with our ETF Search.
  • Compare costs, performance, and risk side by side.
  • Save your favourites to a watchlist and receive price alerts.
  • Explore detailed ETF profiles with key metrics and holdings.

Key Differences Among Crypto ETPs

UK investors can trade many crypto ETPs on European exchanges, and Germany is a popular place to do so. More than half a dozen Bitcoin ETPs are now listed on Xetra, the trading platform of Deutsche Börse. Many are also listed on the SIX Swiss Exchange.

With so many providers, products are structured differently, so investors should weigh several factors to find the crypto ETP that best suits their needs.

Bitcoin accounts for about half of the total market capitalisation of all cryptocurrencies, so our overview focuses on products linked to the leading cryptocurrency. There are also many products based on other altcoins, and the same selection criteria apply to these.

Who approved the crypto ETP, and where is the regulatory authority located?

The European Union is considered a leader in cryptocurrency regulation. In 2015, for example, the first regulator-approved crypto ETP was listed for trading in Europe. There are now more than 90 crypto ETPs. In general, the EU aims to protect investors without hindering the development of cryptocurrencies in the financial markets. From 2024, the “Markets in Crypto Assets” (MiCA) regulation will take effect, under which only providers authorised by a national financial regulator will be permitted to operate in this market within the EU.

In Germany, ETPs have been launched by the ETC Group, Fidelity and Deutsche Digital Assets. In Switzerland, the providers include 21Shares and Ficas; XBT is based in Sweden and VanEck in Liechtenstein. In the Channel Islands of Jersey and Guernsey, providers include CoinShares, WisdomTree, Global X and Seba Bank.

To obtain authorisation, all providers must submit a prospectus to a financial regulator for approval. Germany’s regulator, BaFin (the equivalent of the UK’s Financial Conduct Authority), has explicitly made consumer protection a priority and has a reputation for particularly thorough reviews. The pioneer in this area was the ETC Group, followed by Deutsche Digital Assets, Fidelity and Invesco. The other providers obtain prospectus approval from the Swedish FAS, SIX Exchange Regulation AG in Switzerland, the Financial Market Authority in Liechtenstein or the Jersey Financial Services Commission, even if the crypto ETP’s registered office is in a different country.

For clarity, it is preferable for the regulator and the crypto ETP’s registered office to be in the same country, but this is not the case for products from Global X, Seba, WisdomTree and Ficas.

Crypto ETPs Add Cryptocurrencies to Your Portfolio

Bild von Jan Altmann, ETC GroupJan Altmann, Bitwise
Crypto ETPs offer investors a safe and convenient way to enter the world of cryptocurrencies. But with so many options available, the trick is knowing how to choose: the right criteria pave the way to a successful investment.
Jan Altmann, Bitwise

Shipping option: Yes or No!

Two features directly affect investors and are particularly important: physical custody and the delivery option. All products except those from Sweden’s XBT are 100 per cent physically backed. This means the issuer holds Bitcoin equal to the amount invested, rather than replicating the currency’s price performance through derivatives. This significantly reduces issuer risk: if the issuer defaults, the investment is backed by the collateral.

With four providers – the ETC Group, Deutsche Digital Assets, VanEck and CoinShares – investors are also entitled to the underlying cryptocurrency and can have it delivered instead of selling their ETP shares on the exchange.

This principle will be familiar to many investors in Deutsche Börse’s Xetra Gold. It can also bring a tax advantage: in Germany, gains from products with a physical delivery option are tax-free after one year (although losses can then no longer be offset), but gains are taxable if the shares are sold within the first year. Tax rules differ in the UK, where cryptoasset gains are generally subject to Capital Gains Tax, so check the current HMRC rules or speak to a tax adviser.

Who lends out cryptocurrencies?

Crypto lending is a hot topic in the world of digital currencies. Custodians lend investors’ bitcoins to third parties to earn extra income, but, as past events have shown, this carries high risks. In a volatile market, a borrower could default, which could ultimately destabilise the provider too. This has already happened with crypto exchanges.

Providers of crypto ETPs generally avoid this risky practice – lending is explicitly excluded in their prospectuses. Only 21Shares keeps this option open. Investors can therefore avoid the risk by choosing another provider.

Who actually holds my crypto ETPs?

The depositary also plays an important role in security, as many investors know from equity funds. For example, the assets of a fund from Provider A may be held in custody by competitor B, because equity funds are special investment funds that are protected even if the provider goes bankrupt. No such rules yet exist for crypto ETPs, but providers are still striving for transparency and security. All the providers mentioned here, except Fidelity and Seba, use an independent custodian to safeguard the physically held bitcoins.

The larger the ETP, the higher the liquidity

As with shares, the larger the volume of a crypto ETP, the more actively it tends to be traded. This is good for liquidity, as it lets investors buy and sell shares easily. At the end of October 2023, the ETC Group Physical Bitcoin, with a volume of €782 million, was the largest crypto ETP on the market, and it trades actively. Physical backing is an advantage here, as market makers on the exchange face fewer risks. The other products trail far behind: only five others have volumes in the hundreds of millions.

Costs of Crypto ETPs

Fees also matter when choosing a crypto ETP, as high fees can significantly erode returns over a long investment horizon. The cost of a product is measured by its total expense ratio (TER), which shows the total annual cost.

Costs for popular crypto ETPs range from 0.21% for Switzerland’s 21Shares Bitcoin Core ETP to 2.50% for XBT’s Bitcoin Tracker Europe in Sweden. Almost all the others charge between 0.95% and 2.00%. Here is a list of all crypto ETPs.

Conclusion:
Crypto ETPs – Simple, Secure, and Regulated

In summary, crypto ETPs offer investors a safe and easy way to invest in cryptocurrencies without the risks of unregulated crypto exchanges.

When choosing one, however, consider several criteria: regulation, the provider’s location, physical custody, delivery options, the custodian’s security measures, liquidity and costs.

Cost should never be the only deciding factor, so weigh the other characteristics above too. Click the link below for further analysis of the available crypto ETPs.

Key Considerations When Selecting Crypto ETPs