Buy crypto directly or through a crypto ETP?

What are the differences?


Investing in cryptocurrencies is becoming increasingly popular. Some professionals, including the CEO of BlackRock, the world’s largest asset manager, already regard Bitcoin as digital gold. For these investors, holding and storing the asset as securely as possible is paramount. Others place great importance on tradability and see crypto trading as a source of quick returns, in which case security of storage inevitably takes a back seat.

Approaches to investing in cryptocurrencies are as varied as investment goals, and the ways of holding them differ fundamentally too.

In this guide, we explain the pros and cons of trading and storing cryptocurrencies, as well as the hurdles, risks and costs crypto investors should expect.

The essentials in brief:
Everything You Need to Know About Crypto ETPs and Direct Purchases at a Glance

  • Crypto ETPs: Crypto ETPs passively track the performance of cryptocurrencies. An ETP (exchange-traded product) can be traded on an exchange and is legally a debt security. Investors do not own the cryptocurrencies directly but gain exposure to their price movements.

  • Direct crypto investment: This means buying cryptocurrencies directly on a crypto exchange. Depending on the wallet, buying and storing these digital assets can be complicated.

  • Wallets: Cryptocurrencies are stored digitally in wallets. With a cold wallet, which can be kept offline, the investor keeps the private keys to the coins. With a hot wallet, the crypto exchange holds the keys.

  • Taxes on cryptocurrencies: According to HMRC, cryptoassets are not treated as money but as assets for tax purposes. Gains made when you sell or otherwise dispose of them are therefore subject to Capital Gains Tax, just like gains on shares or other investments. For more information on the taxation of cryptocurrencies, see our article on the subject.

Advert
Get started with ETF investing

Find and compare thousands of ETFs. Use powerful filters, detailed analytics, and independent data to discover the right ETF for your portfolio.

Three Ways to Invest in Cryptocurrencies

There are three main ways to invest in cryptocurrencies.

  1. The first is to buy cryptocurrencies directly into a personal wallet (cold wallet). In this case, the investor takes full ownership of the digital currency, which offers a degree of control and security but also brings the responsibility of keeping it safe.
  2. The second option is to buy and store cryptocurrencies through crypto exchanges or brokers (hot wallet). This method is flexible but requires a degree of trust in the trading platforms.
  3. The third option is crypto exchange-traded products (ETPs), which let investors gain exposure to cryptocurrencies without owning them. These products make crypto markets easier to access and allow for diversification, but they also carry the risks of traditional financial instruments.

Each option has its own advantages and disadvantages, and the right choice depends on your preferences, knowledge and risk tolerance. Below, we take a closer look at all three.

Join the extraETF community

Werde Teil der extraETF Community

Explore the world of ETFs and make informed investment decisions.

  • Find ETFs that match your criteria with our ETF Search.
  • Compare costs, performance, and risk side by side.
  • Save your favourites to a watchlist and receive price alerts.
  • Explore detailed ETF profiles with key metrics and holdings.

Your Own Cold Wallet – The Theory Is Simple, but It's Complicated

Anyone who wants to invest in cryptocurrencies like Bitcoin or Ethereum can exchange conventional money (which crypto fans call “fiat money”) for cryptocurrencies on an exchange. The coins are then kept in a personal wallet, which can also be offline. Numerous crypto exchanges offer this service. However, pricing isn’t easy to understand, and buying or transferring cryptocurrencies also costs money, paid in coins. After all, nothing can be written to the blockchain for free – especially not with Bitcoin or Ethereum.

Buying and storing cryptocurrencies yourself seems complicated to many investors. Whenever you transfer coins, you should check the destination address two or three times. A transfer sent to the wrong address is lost for good, and there is no refund. For crypto enthusiasts, however, this is the only sensible way to stay in control of the keys to their coins.

Crypto Exchanges, aka Crypto Brokers

Many investors prefer to deposit their cryptocurrency balances with a crypto exchange. The exchange sets up a wallet for each user, but it works only within the exchange’s own systems. This is known as a hot wallet. The exchange manages the assets in a large collective pool, and the operator controls the users’ keys. In the crypto world, many enthusiasts warn against handing wallet keys to third parties (“not your key, not your coin”).

The best-known providers currently include Binance, Coinbase, Crypto.com, Kraken and Bitpanda. In these cases, the provider holds the keys, not the investor. Crypto brokers, usually via a mobile app, also let you trade cryptocurrencies. Tokens can often be transferred back from the exchange to your own hardware wallet. Because many crypto exchanges manage investors’ assets in hot wallets, rather than simply exchanging fiat currency for coins, financial regulation should technically apply. Some providers comply, but unregulated crypto brokers still exist, and since autumn 2022 – think of the collapse of the FTX exchange – they have been constantly in the headlines.

Crypto ETPs as an Alternative

If you have to hand over the keys to your blockchain holdings, it is better to entrust them to established, regulated professionals from the conventional financial sector. Investors do not hold the keys with crypto ETPs either, but the providers hold the coins in custody and document this. Every step, from trading to holding to selling, goes through regulated financial services providers. Crypto ETPs are also admitted to trading on a regulated exchange under a prospectus, which imposes numerous obligations on providers. The regulator monitors compliance.

Legally, ETPs are debt securities issued by special-purpose vehicles set up for that purpose. Some ETP providers invest 100 per cent of their assets in cryptocurrencies, meaning the securities are physically backed. If the provider defaults, the cryptocurrencies held as collateral belong to the investors.

Other providers track the performance of the underlying asset synthetically, so there is no “default protection” from collateral. Some also use leverage or lend out the digital assets to boost their own margins, which adds to the risk. If the issuer goes bankrupt, investors are likely to lose their money too. It’s worth taking a close look at this product category.

The basic principle behind this structure, however, is familiar from multi-billion-pound gold ETCs. Genuine crypto ETFs would be better still, but regulators aren’t there yet.

Trading works as it does with ETFs: multiple market makers ensure that crypto ETPs trade closely in line with the price movements of the underlying cryptocurrency. To invest in ETPs, you simply need a standard investment account with a bank or an online broker. The largest providers of these securities include ETC Group, 21Shares, CoinShares, VanEck and WisdomTree.

Speaking of gold ETCs: if you have questions about how they are taxed, our article on the topic is well worth reading.

Trade around the clock or during market hours?

When it comes to tradability, crypto brokers have the edge over ETPs. Trading takes place around the clock – even on weekends.

ETPs work much like ETFs: they have an ISIN and trade on numerous regulated venues (exchanges), so most trading volume occurs during core trading hours.

On the London Stock Exchange, for example, prices are quoted on weekdays between 8am and 4.30pm. Some platforms also offer trading later into the evening. However, there is no trading at night or at weekends.

Differences in availability

The wider crypto market offers a vast array of digital assets, including around 20,000 digital currencies (Bitcoin and altcoins). Unregulated crypto exchanges offer the widest choice. Regulated direct providers and crypto ETP providers are a different story: crypto ETPs track only 25 currencies. However, these 25 currencies account for nearly 90 per cent of the total market value of all cryptocurrencies.

On the plus side, crypto ETPs can track several cryptocurrencies systematically, for example through an index, much like an ETF.

Minimum investment requirements are not a barrier

One Bitcoin currently costs around US$30,000. However, this shouldn’t deter investors, because no one has to buy a whole Bitcoin. Bitcoin can be divided into very small fractions, so you can invest even with small amounts. This applies both to direct investments via a digital wallet and to buying ETPs. Minimum investment amounts are low, and online brokers now accept very small orders too.

ETPs make it possible to include cryptocurrencies in a portfolio

Bild von Jan Altmann, ETC GroupJan Altmann, Bitwise
Crypto ETPs offer a regulated alternative to buying cryptocurrencies directly. They can be traded through established financial service providers and are subject to strict oversight. Many crypto ETPs also hold the purchased cryptocurrency in custody, which further enhances security.
Jan Altmann, Bitwise

Trading fees: why it pays to understand them

There are always fees when trading cryptocurrencies: providers need to cover their costs and make a profit. This applies even when providers advertise commission-free trading, because the spread between the buy and sell prices then funds the service.

On unregulated trading platforms, fees start at 0.02 per cent and can be lower still for high trading volumes. On regulated platforms, fees typically range from 1.25 per cent to 1.49 per cent per trade.

Trading ETPs generally involves the same fee structure as trading ETFs. On some trading venues, certain brokers charge no transaction fees at all, while others charge a few pounds per trade. ETP trading is at least as transparent on fees as trading ETFs. Costs also include the spread between the bid and ask prices, which you should factor in when trading more exotic ETPs.

Regular Crypto Investments – Save Regularly in Crypto

Some trading platforms offer regular investment plans for cryptocurrencies, but the hot wallet issue remains.

You can also invest regularly in crypto ETPs, although not every broker offers this.

Taxation – The Differences Lie in the Details

Anyone who invests directly in cryptocurrencies and realises gains may have to pay Capital Gains Tax on them. Gains above the annual exempt amount are taxable, at rates that depend on your income tax band. HMRC treats it as a disposal whether you convert the cryptocurrency into a regular currency, spend it, or exchange it for another cryptocurrency on an exchange.

Gains within your annual exempt amount are not subject to Capital Gains Tax, but you may still need to report them to HMRC.

The tax treatment of crypto ETPs and ETCs depends on how they are structured and where you hold them. Gains on ETPs held outside a tax-advantaged account are generally subject to Capital Gains Tax, just like gains on ETFs. If you are unsure how your holdings will be taxed, check HMRC’s guidance or speak to a tax adviser.

For more detail on how crypto gains are taxed, see our in-depth article on cryptocurrency taxation.

Conclusion:
Who are cryptocurrencies suitable for?

Whether to buy cryptocurrencies directly or through a crypto ETP depends on your preferences, your knowledge of crypto, the terms of crypto exchanges or brokers, tradability, costs, your risk tolerance and your tax position.

Buying cryptocurrencies directly requires a wallet. If you want to keep control of the keys to your coins, you can opt for a cold wallet. However, these are cumbersome to set up and carry risks of their own. With hot wallets, you should also check whether the crypto exchange or broker is regulated.

Crypto ETPs suit investors who prefer to trade through regulated financial services providers and are comfortable leaving the keys to their crypto holdings with the ETP provider.

Important Questions About Crypto ETPs or Buying Directly