Tracking Difference for ETFs
An important metric for selecting ETFs.
The ETF industry has been growing for years, and as it grows, so does the number of ETFs available. With so many ETFs to choose from, it’s easy to lose track – especially since there are now often multiple ETFs tracking the same index. But not all ETFs are created equal! So how can you choose the right ETF for your investment strategy?
An important metric for selecting an ETF is the tracking difference. It helps you find the best ETF for your portfolio. The tracking difference lets you see how the ETF has performed compared to its index.
In this article, we’ll explain the basics of tracking difference and show you how to use it to identify the best ETF.
The essentials in brief: What You Should Know About the Tracking Difference
Performance: An ETF may outperform or underperform its benchmark index.
Best Practices: An ETF’s accuracy in tracking its benchmark depends on various factors (e.g., tax optimization, cash holdings, income from securities lending).
Selecting an ETF: The tracking difference should be a key consideration when choosing an ETF. Investors who invest in an ETF expect it to track the index as closely as possible. The tracking difference makes this clear.
Analysis: ETF specialists such as extraETF.com display the tracking difference for each ETF on the ETF profile page and in the ETF search results.
Find and compare thousands of ETFs. Use powerful filters, detailed analytics, and independent data to discover the right ETF for your portfolio.
What is the tracking difference?
The tracking difference reflects how well an ETF has performed relative to the index and thus reveals the actual costs of an ETF or index fund.
Unlike actively managed investment funds, where the success of fund managers is measured by their ability to outperform a benchmark index, exchange-traded funds (ETFs) are designed to track the performance of an index as closely as possible.
What is the significance of the tracking difference?
The tracking difference is used to assess the quality of an ETF. It is generally defined as the deviation between the ETF’s performance and that of the underlying index over a given period.
Tracking Difference = ETF Performance – Index Performance
An ETF investor’s expected return will generally correspond to the index’s performance minus the total expense ratio (TER).
The tracking difference includes all costs and fees associated with an ETF and also takes into account, among other things, income from securities lending. It therefore provides a much more accurate picture of an ETF’s actual costs than the total expense ratio (TER). The closer the tracking difference tends toward 0, the more accurately the index is tracked.
Investors should note that the tracking difference is calculated based on past performance and cannot be directly extrapolated to the future. It is therefore worthwhile to examine an ETF’s tracking difference over longer periods. This is the only way to determine whether the ETF provider has been able to maintain the ETF’s tracking quality even during different market phases.
Did you know? Calculating the Tracking Difference on extraETF.com
Contrary to the definition described above, extraETF.com calculates the tracking difference using the following formula.
Tracking Difference = Index Performance – ETF Performance
This has the advantage of allowing the tracking difference to be better contextualized in relation to the total expense ratio.
An ETF with a TER of 0.50% and a tracking difference of 0.15% has therefore actually cost the investor only 0.15%, which is less than the stated TER. The 0.35% difference was earned by the ETF provider through various optimization methods and contributed to the ETF’s performance.
The tracking difference can be found on extraETF.com for many ETFs on the ETF profile pages (e.g., MSCI World ETF) and in the ETF search.
Example: Tracking Difference of an MSCI World ETF
To assess the significance of the tracking difference, let’s examine this metric for the popular iShares Core MSCI World ETF.
The total expense ratio (TER) of this ETF is 0.20% per year. This raises the question of how large the ETF’s actual deviation from its benchmark index, the MSCI World, actually was. This deviation is expressed by the tracking difference metric.

The average annual tracking difference since the launch of the iShares Core MSCI World UCITS ETF (Acc) was 0.05%. This means the ETF underperformed the index by an average of 0.05%. This is very good, as the ETF’s total expense ratio (TER) is 0.20%. The ETF provider has thus managed to generate additional returns for its investors, thereby offsetting a portion of the fund’s costs.
The Best Metric for Choosing an ETF
Why can an ETF outperform an index despite its fees?
As described earlier, the tracking accuracy of an ETF is an important competitive factor for ETF providers. They therefore seek to minimise the tracking difference as much as possible through various optimization measures.
This optimization is a complex process, as factors other than the ETF’s costs (TER) also influence the quality of an ETF’s tracking.
- Index rebalancing: Index rebalancing incurs costs; the more frequently it occurs, the larger the tracking difference.
- Dividends: Net dividends and delays in receiving foreign dividends increase the tracking difference; this is a bigger problem for physically replicated ETFs than for swap ETFs.
- Cash holdings: Dividends result in cash holdings; not every ETF reinvests dividends immediately. Cash holdings cause underperformance when prices rise (cash drag).
- Taxes: Net-return indices deduct the maximum withholding tax rate from dividends; in practice, however, ETFs often pay less in taxes, leading to outperformance relative to the index.
- Type of index replication: Optimised replication; this results in slight tracking errors.
- Income from securities lending: This income provides additional revenue and thus leads to outperformance relative to the index.
- Swap fees or swap income: These result in an additional deviation from the index.
- Execution quality: The fund company’s expertise and various replication techniques can lead to a deviation from the index.
- Fees: Fees place a permanent burden on the fund and thus automatically result in a tracking difference.
Join the extraETF community
Explore the world of ETFs and make informed investment decisions.
- Find ETFs that match your criteria with our ETF Search.
- Compare costs, performance, and risk side by side.
- Save your favourites to a watchlist and receive price alerts.
- Explore detailed ETF profiles with key metrics and holdings.
How should we interpret the tracking difference?
The tracking difference indicates the extent to which an ETF has outperformed or underperformed the index. But what does a negative or positive tracking difference mean for an ETF?
Does it make sense to select ETFs based on tracking difference?
When selecting an ETF, investors consider various criteria. Until now, they have tended to prioritize the total expense ratio (TER), the ETF’s performance, or its assets under management. Depending on how the ETF is used, factors such as the spread, liquidity, or distribution type were also often taken into account.
However, the tracking difference should be the primary consideration when selecting an ETF. After all, anyone investing in an ETF expects it to track the index as closely as possible. The tracking difference reveals how well the ETF has achieved this over the selected time period.
It’s worth comparing ETFs, as differences in tracking difference can sometimes be quite significant. Furthermore, the quality of the tracking difference fluctuates over time, as the following example of the iShares STOXX Europe 600 UCITS ETF (DE) illustrates.
| Year | Tracking Difference in % |
|---|---|
| 2021 | - 0.38% |
| 2020 | - 0.10% |
| 2019 | - 0.82% |
| 2018 | + 0.19% |
| 2017 | - 0.21% |
| TD since 2006 | - 0.16% |
An ETF’s total expense ratio (TER) is not a meaningful indicator of its quality when considered in isolation. This is because, contrary to expectations (ETF return = index return – TER), there can be significant differences between the TER and the tracking difference. It is therefore worth monitoring an ETF’s tracking difference from time to time.
Comparison: Tracking Difference vs. Total Cost Ratio
The following example illustrates the significant differences between the total expense ratio (TER) and the 3-year tracking difference for the ETFs shown.
The table shows the five largest ETFs tracking the MSCI World Index. Despite a TER ranging from 0.15% to 0.50% per year, nearly all of these ETFs have a negative tracking difference over a three-year period.
This means that four of the listed MSCI World ETFs have outperformed the benchmark index. The ETF providers were able to generate additional returns through various optimizations, thereby more than offsetting the ETFs’ costs. In this scenario, the best ETF tracking the MSCI World Index is the HSBC MSCI World UCITS ETF (Dist) with a tracking difference of -0.21%.
| ETF | Total Expense Ratio (TER) in % | 3-Year Tracking Difference in % |
|---|---|---|
| iShares Core MSCI World UCITS ETF (Acc) | 0.20% | - 0.08% |
| Xtrackers MSCI World UCITS ETF (Acc) | 0.19% | - 0.06% |
| iShares MSCI World UCITS ETF (Dist) | 0.50% | + 0.25% |
| HSBC MSCI World UCITS ETF (Distribution) | 0.15% | - 0.21% |
| Lyxor MSCI World UCITS ETF (Distribution) | 0.30% | - 0.08% |
What is tracking error?
The tracking error of an ETF is often mistakenly confused with the tracking difference. While the tracking difference measures the actual deviation of the ETF’s performance from that of the index over a specific period, the tracking error represents the variation of the ETF’s price around the index’s mean – that is, the standard deviation of the fund’s return relative to the index’s performance.
The lower the tracking error, the more closely the ETF tracks its index. This is important because ETF investors always want their investment to track the index as closely as possible. Both metrics can be used to assess the quality of an ETF.
Are there differences in the way the index is tracked?
All ETF providers aim to achieve the lowest possible tracking difference for their ETFs. Some ETFs even have a negative tracking difference. In these cases, the ETF has actually outperformed the index. The general reasons for this have already been explained. In addition, the type of index replication offers both advantages and disadvantages with regard to the ETF’s tracking difference.
Synthetically replicated ETFs offer the highest replication accuracy, as the swap partner always guarantees an exact replication of the index.
Where can I find the tracking difference?
The tracking difference can be found on extraETF.com on an ETF's profile pages and in the ETF search (Tracking Difference tab). In addition, many ETF providers also display the tracking difference on their websites.
Here you can view the tracking difference for the Vanguard FTSE All-World UCITS ETF (Dist).

Conclusion: The Best Metric for Selecting ETFs
The tracking difference is undoubtedly one of the most important metrics for assessing the quality of an ETF. It shows how the ETF has performed relative to its benchmark (index).
Investors can also consider other metrics when selecting an ETF. Good options here include the total expense ratio (TER), the fund’s assets under management, or the type of distribution.
Using the ETF search tool, all tradable ETFs can be analysed and compared based on key metrics.
Frequently Asked Questions About Tracking Difference
- What You Should Know About the Tracking Difference
- What is the tracking difference?
- What is the significance of the tracking difference?
- Calculating the Tracking Difference on extraETF.com
- Why can an ETF outperform an index despite its fees?
- How should we interpret the tracking difference?
- Does it make sense to select ETFs based on tracking difference?
- Comparison: Tracking Difference vs. Total Cost Ratio
- What is tracking error?
- Are there differences in the way the index is tracked?
- Where can I find the tracking difference?
- The Best Metric for Selecting ETFs
- Frequently Asked Questions About Tracking Difference
